Sunny Storage · Clermont, Florida

Self-Storage Tenant Insurance & Protection Plans (2026)

Open 10x30 drive-up storage unit at Sunny Storage in Clermont, FL

By i4 Capital Group

A storage lease rents empty space. It does not, by itself, pay for a tenant’s sofa, documents or inventory if something goes wrong inside the unit. That gap is why almost every operator ends up talking about insurance or a protection plan at move-in: either the tenant brings coverage from home, or the facility offers an optional product, or both.

This guide is for people who develop, own or run self-storage in Florida. It explains how the largest public operators describe their tenant programs, what Florida’s limited-line insurance license requires when you sell insurance at the counter or online, and a practical checklist you can run before the next move-in. For the software that usually hosts these products at checkout, see our self-storage management software comparison. For unpaid rent and lien sales, see our Florida self-storage lien law guide.

Sunny Storage at 1140 Hooks St, Clermont, FL is the real facility behind this hub. Designed and built by i4 Capital Group, owned and operated by Sunny Storage, an affiliated company. We mention it only as context. This article does not describe any Sunny insurance product, attach rate or claim result.

Not legal or insurance advice. The Florida sections summarize the 2026 Florida Statutes. Laws and product filings change. Check the current law, your insurer’s appointments and a Florida attorney before you sell, require or refuse any product.

All sources below were checked on November 6, 2026.

The short version

Why operators care about tenant coverage

Three separate risks sit next to each other at every facility:

  1. Damage to the buildings and the business. That is the operator’s commercial property and liability insurance.
  2. Damage or loss of the tenant’s personal property. That is usually the tenant’s problem under the rental agreement, unless a statute, a court or a special contract says otherwise.
  3. Unpaid rent and the lien process. That is a different path, covered by Florida’s Self-storage Facility Act (ss. 83.801–83.809). Do not mix lien notices with insurance claims.

Section 83.803 of the 2026 Florida Statutes defines a self-service storage facility as real property rented so tenants can store and remove personal property, and it says no individual storage space may be used for residential purposes. The same act defines the rental agreement and the parties. It does not create a duty for the owner to insure the tenant’s goods. That is why operators write risk-allocation clauses into the lease and why they offer optional coverage or ask for proof of the tenant’s own policy.

Florida also lets the parties set a contractual value limit. Under s. 83.806(9) of the 2026 Florida Statutes, if the rental agreement contains a limit on the value of property stored in the storage space, that limit is “deemed to be the maximum value of the property stored in such space.” That clause is about the lease, not about an insurance policy. Keep it separate from any optional coverage you sell.

Florida’s definition of insurance, in s. 624.02, is a contract in which one party undertakes to indemnify another or pay a specified amount or determinable benefit upon determinable contingencies. If your “protection” product fits that definition, treat it as insurance. That alone does not place it within the limited license below: confirm with counsel and your insurer that it meets s. 626.321(1)(g), including that it covers only personal property not held for resale, before you use that license path. If you are unsure, stop and ask Florida counsel before marketing it.

Tenants often assume “the facility is insured,” meaning their boxes are covered. A clear conversation at move-in avoids that mistake before a claim appears. The Florida Department of Financial Services’ renters insurance overview notes that personal property coverage on a renters policy often follows belongings away from the home, with limits and sublimits. That is one reason s. 626.321(1)(g) requires written notice that a homeowner’s policy may already cover the loss.

Insurance vs protection plan: use the words the product uses

Operators and vendors use several labels: tenant insurance, customer goods protection, storage protection plan, certificate of insurance. The label matters because insurance is regulated as insurance, and other contractual products may be regulated differently.

What the three largest U.S. public self-storage companies say in their Form 10-K filings for fiscal year 2025 (filed with the SEC in February 2026):

Public Storage

Public Storage describes an “Other Operations” line in which it manages insurance programs so tenants “have the option of purchasing insurance from a non-affiliated insurance company to cover certain losses to their stored goods.” A wholly owned, consolidated subsidiary “fully reinsures these policies and thereby assumes all risk of losses under the policies,” and receives reinsurance premiums “substantially equal to the premiums collected from our tenants.” The filing states those policies cover claims for losses related to specified events “up to a maximum limit of $5,000 per storage unit,” that Public Storage reinsures all risks in the program but buys third-party cover for losses above $10.0 million per occurrence (up to a $15.0 million limit), and that at December 31, 2025 there were about 1.5 million certificates held by participating tenants, representing about $7.2 billion of aggregate coverage.

Extra Space Storage

Extra Space’s “Other Operations” section says its “tenant reinsurance activities include the reinsurance of risks relating to the loss of goods stored by tenants in our stores.” Customers “have the option of purchasing insurance from a non-affiliated insurance company” for goods stored at Extra Space facilities and at stores it manages for third parties. A wholly owned, consolidated subsidiary “fully reinsures such policies and thereby assumes all risk of losses,” receiving reinsurance premiums “substantially equal to the premiums collected from our tenants.” Elsewhere the filing says each tenant chooses the amount of coverage through the tenant reinsurance program, can buy policies “in amounts up to ten thousand dollars,” and that as of December 31, 2025 there were about 1.8 million tenant insurance policies with about $5.7 billion of aggregate coverage. Extra Space’s exposure per claim, the filing says, is limited by the maximum amount of coverage each tenant chose.

CubeSmart

CubeSmart’s accounting note on “Other property related income” says that line “consists of late fees, administrative charges, customer storage protection plan fees, sales of storage supplies and other ancillary revenues” and is recognized when earned. The 2025 Form 10-K does not, in that note, describe a reinsurance structure the way Public Storage and Extra Space do. Treat CubeSmart’s “protection plan” wording as a reminder that not every ancillary product is disclosed as insurance.

For a single-site operator, the lesson is simple: sell only what your carrier and counsel have approved, and use the same product name in the lease, the website, the receipt and the staff script.

Florida limited license for storage personal-property insurance

When the product is insurance covering personal property stored in a self-service storage facility, Florida has a specific limited license.

Under s. 626.321(1)(g) of the 2026 Florida Statutes (“In-transit and storage personal property insurance”), the Department of Financial Services may issue a license for insurance covering only personal property not held for resale, covering storage risks in self-service storage facilities as defined in s. 83.803. The license may be issued, without examination, only to employees or authorized representatives of lessors who rent or lease those spaces and who are authorized by an insurer to issue certificates or other evidence of insurance to lessees under an insurance policy issued to the lessor.

The same paragraph requires a written notice to a prospective purchaser that:

The Florida Department of Financial Services describes this limited line as license type and class 2-31 In-Transit and Storage Personal Property Insurance. Its published steps say the applicant must be at least 18, a U.S. citizen or legal alien with work authorization, a Florida resident for a resident license (or a non-resident for a non-resident license), and an employee or authorized representative of a qualifying lessor authorized by an insurer to issue certificates. The applicant completes an online license application, pays fees, is fingerprinted, and must obtain an appointment with a Florida-authorized insurer. DFS notes that the license expires if it stays unappointed for 48 months (citing s. 626.431(3)).

Section 626.321(5) adds that a limited-class policy or certificate may be sold only when it is offered by an authorized insurer in Florida or an eligible surplus lines insurer in Florida.

None of that replaces advice from your appointed insurer or a Florida insurance lawyer. It does tell you why a casual “protection fee” added to rent without licensing review is a red flag.

Lease wording and the sales conversation

Your rental agreement and your sales flow should say the same things:

  1. Who bears the risk of the stored goods. Most storage leases put that risk on the tenant. Have counsel draft the clause; do not copy a competitor’s PDF.
  2. Any contractual value limit. If you use one, make sure it matches s. 83.806(9) and that staff can explain it without calling it insurance.
  3. Whether proof of coverage is required. Some operators require either the facility’s optional product or evidence of the tenant’s own policy. If you require proof, say what documents you accept and how often you re-check them.
  4. That any facility product is optional when Florida’s limited-license notice applies. Put the written notice from s. 626.321(1)(g) in the checkout path, not only in a binder in the office.
  5. What is covered and what is not. Named perils, exclusions, deductibles, waiting periods and maximum limits belong in the certificate or plan document the tenant can open before paying.
  6. How to file a claim. Give a phone number, a URL and the insurer or administrator name. Do not make the site manager the claims adjuster.

Keep lien enforcement (notices, sale, surplus) on a separate track from insurance claims. Staff who handle both need a written playbook so a delinquency file does not swallow a claim file.

Online checkout deserves the same clarity. Any protection or insurance choice on the website should be obvious and not pre-selected. A silent opt-in is a compliance problem waiting to happen.

What the large-operator numbers do and do not tell you

The Public Storage and Extra Space filings are useful because they are audited disclosures of how two national platforms structure optional coverage:

Operator (FY2025 10-K) Product described Who issues the policy (as disclosed) Stated per-tenant limit Certificates / policies at 2025-12-31
Public Storage Tenant insurance, fully reinsured by a wholly owned subsidiary Non-affiliated insurance company; subsidiary assumes the risk $5,000 per storage unit About 1.5 million certificates
Extra Space Storage Tenant reinsurance / tenant insurance Non-affiliated insurance company; subsidiary assumes the risk Up to $10,000 About 1.8 million policies
CubeSmart Customer storage protection plan fees (reported in other property-related income) Not described as insurance in that accounting note Not stated in that note Not stated in that note

Those figures are about national platforms with millions of units. They are not Florida market averages, and they are not a recommended limit for a single Clermont facility. Use them to ask better questions of your carrier: who is the insurer of record, who holds the risk, what is the per-unit maximum, and what excess cover sits above the program.

Operator checklist before the next move-in

  1. Confirm with counsel whether your product is insurance under s. 624.02, a contractual protection plan, or something else.
  2. If the lease caps the value of stored goods, confirm the wording with counsel under s. 83.806(9).
  3. If it is insurance under s. 626.321(1)(g), confirm every selling employee or authorized representative holds the right limited license and an active insurer appointment.
  4. Put the required written notice (homeowner’s policy may cover; purchase not required) into every sales path: office, phone and website.
  5. Align the lease, the website, the receipt and the staff script on the same product name and the same optional/required rules.
  6. Give tenants a way to open the full certificate or plan terms before they pay.
  7. Separate claim intake from lien enforcement.
  8. Train staff not to describe coverage limits they cannot show in writing.
  9. Re-check appointments and product filings on a calendar (for example, each year when Form 10-K season reminds you that large operators refresh their disclosures).
  10. For climate-controlled units and humidity risk to furniture and documents, point tenants to practical storage guidance such as our climate-controlled storage guide for Clermont without promising that any insurance product will pay a mold claim.

Planning a facility, not just a form

Tenant coverage is an operations product, but it sits next to design and software choices: how the management system presents add-ons, how gate access is issued after payment, and how the lease is signed online. If you are planning a new Central Florida facility and want design-build help, start at the Sunny Storage hub or email ofli@i4capital.com.

Planning a similar project? Email ofli@i4capital.com.

Sources

Not legal or insurance advice. Check current law before acting.

Frequently asked questions

Is tenant insurance the same as a storage protection plan?
Not always. Public Storage and Extra Space Storage describe optional tenant insurance issued by a non-affiliated insurer, with a company subsidiary reinsuring the policies. CubeSmart's annual report lists "customer storage protection plan fees" as other property-related income, without calling that fee an insurance premium. Read the product documents and ask counsel which label fits before you sell it.
Do Florida storage staff need a license to sell tenant insurance?
If you are selling insurance covering personal property stored in a self-service storage facility, Florida's limited license for in-transit and storage personal property insurance (s. 626.321(1)(g), 2026 Florida Statutes) applies. It may be issued, without examination, to employees or authorized representatives of storage lessors who are authorized by an insurer to issue certificates under a policy issued to the lessor. Confirm current licensing steps with the Florida Department of Financial Services.
Can a Florida storage lease require the tenant to buy the facility's insurance?
Section 626.321(1)(g) requires a person licensed under that paragraph to give a prospective purchaser written notice that a homeowner's policy may cover the loss of personal property and that the purchase of such insurance is not required under the lease terms. Build that notice into your sales script and checkout flow.
Do large public operators disclose how their tenant programs work?
Yes. In their Form 10-K filings for fiscal year 2025, Public Storage and Extra Space Storage describe optional coverage from a non-affiliated insurer that a wholly owned subsidiary fully reinsures. Public Storage states a maximum limit of $5,000 per storage unit on those policies; Extra Space says tenants can buy coverage in amounts up to $10,000. Those are their disclosures, not a recommended design for every facility.
Does the facility's property insurance cover a tenant's belongings?
Usually the facility's property policy covers the buildings and the owner's business, not the tenant's personal property. That is why leases often put the risk of stored goods on the tenant and why operators offer optional coverage or ask for proof of the tenant's own policy. Florida also lets a rental agreement set a limit on the value of property stored in a space; under s. 83.806(9), that limit is "deemed to be the maximum value of the property stored in such space." Have a Florida attorney review your lease language.

i4 Capital Group · design-build